Sorry, you need to enable JavaScript to visit this website.
Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Canada

The Tactical Asset Allocation model can provide investment recommendations which diverge from those outlined in our regular weekly publications. The model has a much shorter investment horizon - namely, one month - and thus attempts to capture very tactical opportunities. Meanwhile, our regular recommendations have a longer expected life, anywhere from 3-months to a year (or longer). This difference explains why the recommendations between the two publications can deviate from each other from time to time. Highlights In December, the model underperformed global equities and the S&P in USD and local-currency terms. For January, the model increased its allocation to stocks and reduced its allocation to bonds (Chart 1). Within the equity portfolio, the weighting to euro area stocks was increased. The model boosted its allocation to Canadian and Swedish bonds at the expense of other European markets. The risk index for stocks deteriorated in December, as did the bond risk index. Feature Performance In December, the recommended balanced portfolio gained 2.1% in local-currency terms and 0.8% in U.S. dollar terms (Chart 2). This compares with a gain of 2.9% for the global equity benchmark and a 3.4% gain for the S&P 500 index. Given that the underlying model is structured in local-currency terms, we generally recommend that investors hedge their positions, though we provide other suggestions on currency risk exposure from time to time. The continued bonds selloff was a drag on the model's performance in December. Chart 1Model Weights Chart 2Portfolio Total Returns Weights The model increased its allocation to stocks from 53% to 57%, and trimmed its bond weighting from 47% to 43% (Table 1). The model boosted its equity allocation to Spain by 3 points, Germany by 2 points, Italy by 1 point, Japan by 1 point and France by 1 point. Meanwhile, weightings were reduced in Sweden by 3 points and New Zealand by 1 point. In the fixed-income space, the allocation to Canadian paper was boosted by 5 points, Sweden by 3 points, New Zealand by 2 points. The allocation to Italian bonds was reduced by 6 points, France by 4 points, U.K. by 3 points, and U.S. Treasurys by 1 point. Table 1Model Weights (As Of December 22, 2016) Currency Allocation Local currency-based indicators drive the construction of our model. As such, the performance of the model's portfolio should be compared with the local-currency global equity benchmark. The decision to hedge currency exposure should be made at the client's discretion, though from time to time, we do provide our recommendations. The dollar's attempt at consolidating its gains was cut short by the hawkish Fed. As a result, our Dollar Capitulation Index is back to levels that indicate the rally in the broad trade-weighted dollar could pause. However, unless the new administration pours cold water on expectations of a major fiscal boost, monetary policy divergence will underpin the dollar bull market (Chart 3). Chart 3U.S. Trade-Weighted Dollar* And Capitulation Capital Market Indicators The risk index for commodities improved slightly reflecting a better reading from the momentum indicator. However, this asset class remains excluded from the portfolio (Chart 4). The risk index for global equities remains at the highest level in over two years. Despite this, our model slightly increased its allocation in equities following four consecutive months of reductions (Chart 5). Chart 4Commodity Index And Risk Chart 5Global Stock Market And Risk The deterioration in the value and liquidity indicators for U.S. stocks was offset by some improvement in the momentum reading. As a result, the risk index for U.S. stocks was flat in December (Chart 6). The risk index for euro area equities increased in December and is now at neutral levels. However, even after the latest increase, the risk index for euro area stocks is noticeably lower than the U.S. measure (Chart 7). Positive growth momentum and a weaker currency could provide support for the euro area equities. Chart 6U.S. Stock Market And Risk Chart 7Euro Area Stock Market And Risk The model slightly increased its allocation to German equities despite the deterioration in the risk index (Chart 8). Unlike most of the equity risk indexes in the model's universe, the one for Emerging Asian stocks improved in December. The model kept its allocation to this asset unchanged (Chart 9). Chart 8German Stock Market And Risk Chart 9Emerging Asian Stock Market And Risk The risk index for bonds deteriorated in December, but remains at a historically low-risk level reflecting oversold readings from the momentum indicator. The model has trimmed its allocation to bonds a touch (Chart 10). The risk index for U.S. Treasurys was little changed in December. Despite its very low risk reading, the model is adding allocation to bond markets that feature more oversold conditions. (Chart 11). Chart 10Global Bond Yields And Risk Chart 11U.S. Bond Yields And Risk Canadian bonds remain massively oversold based on our momentum measure, and the overall risk index is at extremely low-risk levels. The model boosted its allocation to this asset (Chart 12). With oversold conditions unwinding and the cyclical indicator moving in a more bond-negative direction, the overall risk index for Italian bonds has shifted back to neutral levels. The model has excluded this asset class from its allocation (Chart 13). Chart 12Canadian Bond Yields And Risk Chart 13Italian Bond Yields and Risk U.K. bonds remain deeply in low-risk territory, despite a small deterioration in its risk index. The oversold reading in the momentum measure is completely overshadowing the negative signal from the cyclical indicator. Allocation to gilts remains one of the highest in the bond universe, even after the model trimmed its exposure to this market (Chart 14). The risk index for Swedish bonds fell once again in December reflecting improved readings in all of its components. Extremely oversold conditions dominate the overall risk index and suggest that a pullback in yields is overdue. The model boosted its allocation to Swedish paper. (Chart 15). Chart 14U.K. Bond Yields And Risk Chart 15Swedish Bond Yields And Risk Currency Technicals The 13-week momentum measure indicates that the dollar's ascent could face near-term resistance. However, the continued recovery in the 40-week rate of change measure suggests that the dollar bull market has more upside. The latest round of central bank meetings reinforces the monetary divergence between the Fed on one side, and the ECB and BoJ on the other (Chart 16). With the prospect of the Bank of Canada staying put, while its southern peer gradually raises rates, the rate differential should exert downward pressure on the CAD/USD. Technically, the breakdown of the longer-term rate-of-change measure is pointing in that direction. In addition, the short-term rate of change metric is not stretched. However, the risk to this view is that the headwinds for the loonie arising from monetary policy divergences can be mitigated by higher oil prices (Chart 17). With the BoJ pegging nominal JGB yields, the differential in real rates is supportive of a stronger USD/JPY. This cyclical outlook for the yen is being confirmed by the 40-week rate of change measure. That said, the 13-week momentum measure is at levels that have signaled a pause in the yen weakening trend in both 2013 and 2015 (Chart 18). Chart 16U.S. Trade-Weighted Dollar* Chart 17Canadian Dollar Chart 18Yen Miroslav Aradski, Senior Analyst miroslava@bcaresearch.com
Highlights Global Duration: Global bond yields, pushed higher since July on the back of improving global growth and rising inflation, have now overshot to the upside on excessive expectations of U.S. fiscal stimulus. Take profits on bearish bond positions and increase portfolio duration exposure to at-benchmark on a tactical basis until the oversold conditions unwind. 2017 Global Yield Curve Expectations: The recent steepening of government bond yield curves across the developed markets should soon begin to fade, leading to a more diverse evolution of curves during the course of 2017: steeper in the U.S., core Europe and in Japan (at the long end), flatter in the U.K., Canada, Australia and New Zealand. U.K. Inflation Protection: Take profits on our recommended U.K. inflation trades (overweight inflation-linked bonds and CPI swaps), in response to the recent stability of the Pound and signs that the Bank of England is shifting in a more hawkish direction. Feature Time To Tactically Take Profits On Short Duration Positions Investors have been reminded over the past few months that boring old bonds, just like equities, can generate painful losses when prices disconnect from fundamentals. Back on July 19, we moved to a below-benchmark stance on overall portfolio duration, as we noted that government bonds across the developed markets had reached an overbought extreme despite improving trends in global growth and inflation (Chart of the Week).1 Bonds have sold off smartly since, with benchmark 10-year government yields in the U.S., U.K., Germany and Japan rising +88bps, +60bps, +36bps, +27bps respectively. The popular market narrative is that the latest leg of the bond selloff is a direct result of Donald Trump winning the White House. This raised investor awareness to the bond-bearish implications of a protectionist U.S. president looking to provide a fiscal kick to an economy already at full employment. The reality, however, is that global bond yields troughed a full four months before the U.S. elections on the back of a better global growth picture. It is quite possible that the latest bump in yields would have happened even if Trump did not win the election. Rising industrial commodity prices, happening in the face of a strengthening U.S. dollar that typically dampens prices, also suggest that bond yields have been responding more to faster realized growth and inflation and less to future expected fiscal stimulus (Chart 2). Chart of the WeekGlobal Bonds##br## Are Oversold Chart 2Stronger Growth Has ##br## Pushed Yields Higher Looking ahead, if the global economy evolves as we expect, with growth continuing to look relatively robust and inflation continuing to grind higher, then yields have even more upside in 2017. However, bonds now appear deeply oversold amid highly bearish sentiment. U.S. Treasury yields, in particular, have overshot the fair value estimates from our models (Chart 3). Also, this week's ECB meeting is unlikely to provide any bearish surprises for bond investors, as the ECB will likely extend the current QE program (at the current pace of buying) until at least next September. This should act to cap the recent widening of global bond term premia (Chart 4) and prevent a "Fifth Tantrum" from unfolding in global bond markets, as we discussed last week.2 Therefore, we are taking profits today on our bearish bond call and moving back to a tactical at-benchmark portfolio duration stance. However, we still expect yields to rise over the next year to levels beyond current forward rates.3 Thus, we would look to reinstate a below-benchmark duration posture if the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield were to fall to the 2-2.2% range. We will also look for signs of oversold momentum fading and a reduction in short positioning in U.S. Treasuries before re-establishing a below-benchmark duration tilt (Chart 5). The next leg of pressure on global bond yields should come from the U.S., given our optimistic view on U.S. growth and inflation for next year (see below). Chart 3UST Yields Are##br## A Bit Too High Chart 4A Big Adjustment In##br## Term Premia & Expectations Chart 5Taking Profits On##br## Our Bearish Bond Call Bottom Line: Global bond yields, pushed higher since July on the back of improving global growth and rising inflation, have now overshot to the upside on excessive expectations of U.S. fiscal stimulus. Take profits on bearish bond positions and increase portfolio duration exposure to at-benchmark on a tactical basis until the oversold conditions unwind. Some Initial Thoughts On Developed Market Yield Curves In 2017 With only a handful of trading days remaining in 2016, it is time to peer ahead to how markets could perform in the New Year. We will be publishing our full 2017 Outlook report on December 20th, but this week we are presenting some preliminary ideas on how government bond yield curves could evolve over the course of next year. United States - Eventual Bear Steepening In Excess Of The Forwards We see U.S. growth accelerating to a 2.8% pace next year, an above-potential pace that is stronger than current consensus forecasts.4 Combined with a steady grind higher in realized inflation (both headline and core), this will generate a nominal growth outcome over 5% in 2017. This will help push the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield to the 2.8-3.0% area by the end of 2017 as the Fed will likely continue to raise rates but not as fast as nominal growth will accelerate (i.e. will remain accommodative). This move will be led by rising inflation expectations, which we see rising to a level consistent with the Fed's inflation target.5 This will put steepening pressure on the U.S. Treasury curve, at a pace that will easily exceed the flattening currently priced into the forwards (Chart 6, top panel). We see the potential for curve steepening pressure to come both from growth, which will push up longer-dated real yields and steepen the "real" yield curve, and from inflation, with a tight labor market putting upward pressure on wage and price inflation even with a stronger U.S. dollar (Chart 7). Chart 6A Steeper UST Curve,##br## Led By Rising Real Yields Chart 7Will UST Yields Pause##br## After A Rate Hike Next Week? For now, however, we are keeping a "neutral" stance on U.S. yield curve exposure until we see signs that oversold conditions in the Treasury market have corrected. One final point: the Treasury market likely moved too quickly in recent weeks to discount a fiscal ease under the new Trump administration. However, any impetus to growth from the government sector, coming at a time when the U.S. economy is running near full employment, will be another structural factor putting steepening pressure on the yield curve in the next year through more Treasury issuance and stronger inflation pressures. Core Euro Area - Very Modest Steepening In Line With The Forwards As we discussed in a recent Weekly Report, the ECB will most likely continue with its current bond-buying program, with no tapering of the size of the purchases, until at least September 2017.6 European inflation remains too low relative to the ECB's target (Chart 8) and the central bank will be wary about reducing monetary stimulus anytime soon. The overriding presence of ECB buying will act to limit the upside in longer-dated European bond yields, even in an environment where U.S. Treasury yields rise over the course of 2017. The core European government bond yield curves (Germany, France) will likely still see some modest steepening pressure, led by upward pressure on real yields, as global growth continues to improve. Combined with the lagged impact of the weakening Euro and the rise in commodity prices, there should be some mild additional steepening pressure coming from inflation expectations, as well. The forward curves are currently pricing in a very modest steepening over the next year, and we do not see a case for the curve to steepen much beyond the forwards (Chart 9). We continue to favor core Europe as a recommended overweight in our global Developed Market bond allocation. Favoring the longer-end of the curve (10 years and longer) in Germany and France - the higher yielding parts of these low-yielding bond markets - makes the most sense against the backdrop of subdued Euro Area inflation. Chart 8No Threat To Global Bonds##br## From The ECB This Week Chart 9ECB QE Will Limit##br## Any Curve Moves In Europe Japan - Expect Long-End Steepening, Even With Bank Of Japan Curve Targeting The Japanese yield curve is now fairly straightforward to predict, with the Bank of Japan (BoJ) now explicitly targeting the level of JGB yields. The BoJ has committed to keep the 10yr JGB yield at 0% until Japanese inflation expectations overshoot the 2% BoJ target. With inflation expectations currently sitting just above 0%, that goal is now far from being realized. We see very little movement in the 2-10 year part of the JGB curve next year, but we expect the curve beyond 10 years to be more influenced by trends in global bond yields, with the BoJ providing no guidance on the desired level of longer-dated JGB yields. Given our views on a potential bear-steepening of the U.S. Treasury curve in 2017, we expect that the 10/30 JGB curve will also steepen (Chart 10). Focusing Japanese bond exposure on the 10-year point makes the most sense in this environment, although at a yield of 0% the return prospects are hardly inviting. U.K. - Steepening Will Turn To Flattening The Bank of England (BoE) took out a very large insurance policy on the U.K. economy by cutting interest rates and re-starting quantitative easing (QE) after the shocking Brexit vote. This has appeared to work, as U.K. economic growth has been surprisingly strong in the months since the June referendum. But the ramifications of the BoE's aggressive easing was a massive depreciation of the Pound and a subsequent rise in U.K. inflation (Chart 11). Chart 10BoJ Is Not Worrying About##br## The Long End For JGBs Chart 11The Post-Brexit ##br## Adjustment Is Nearly Complete This has set up a situation where the Gilt market is behaving much like the U.S. Treasury market did after the Fed introduced its own QE programs between 2008 & 2012. The result was as rise in nominal bond yields led by rising inflation expectations and stronger economic growth, both of which were a function of a weaker currency. In the case of the U.K. now, the rise in inflation has been strong enough to force the BoE to back off its promise to deliver an additional rate cut before the end of 2016. The BoE will likely not extend the latest QE program beyond the March 2017 expiry, as well. There is even a chance that the BoE could be forced to hike rates sometime in the first half of 2017. Against this backdrop where the BoE has to play a bit of monetary catchup to rising nominal growth, the Gilt curve is likely to see some flattening pressure after the recent steepening. With the forwards pricing in no change in the slope of the curve next year (Chart 12), curve flattening positions that limit exposure to the front-end of the Gilt curve could offer opportunities in 2017 after global bond yields consolidate the recent rise in yields. While we believe it is too early to reposition our Gilt curve allocation this week, we are taking profits on our recommended U.K. inflation protection trades given the recent stability of the Pound and growing evidence that the Bank of England is turning more hawkish (Chart 13). Specifically, we are closing our Overlay Trade favoring index-linked Gilts versus nominals at a profit of +59bps. We also advise closing our "Brexit hedge" trade suggested in June before the referendum, which was a long position in U.K. CPI swaps versus U.S. equivalents. Chart 12Nearing The End Of ##br## Gilt Curve Steepening? Chart 13Take Profit On U.K.##br## Inflation Protection Trades Canada - The Steepening Is Over A modest steepening of the Canadian government bond yield curve in 2017 is currently priced into the forwards. We think even this small move is unlikely to be realized. The short-end of the yield curve should stay well-anchored around current levels. Probabilities extracted from the Canadian Overnight Index Swap (OIS) curve currently show a 4% market-implied chance of a rate cut, and 40% odds of a rate hike, by December 6th 2017. Of the two, the probability of a rate hike looks too high. The Bank of Canada (BoC) has rarely increased policy rates when our BCA Canadian Central Bank Monitor was in "easy money required" territory (Chart 14). More likely, the Bank of Canada will stay on hold throughout 2017 due to a lack of inflationary pressures. The Canadian unemployment rate remains far higher than the full employment level, while a wide gap has developed between the growth rates of core CPI and weekly earnings; low wage inflation usually drags core CPI inflation lower. Already, the Canadian CPI less the most volatile components - one of the core inflation measures monitored by the BoC - has rolled over. In the longer part of the curve, the weakening economic cycle will keep yields well contained. While the rebound in energy prices seen this year is a positive for the beaten-up Alberta economy, even higher prices will be needed for Canadian energy producers to rekindle investments in that sector given the high cost of oil extraction in Western Canada. Without a meaningful recovery in Alberta, the Canadian economy will be unable to expand at an above-trend pace; growth will be slower than the general consensus forecast of 2.0% in 2017.7 To profit from that view, we are opening a new butterfly spread trade on the Canadian curve: going long the 2-year/10-year barbell versus a short position in the 5-year bullet. This trade should generate positive excess returns if the 2-year/10-year slope of the Canadian curve flattens, as we expect (Chart 15). Chart 14Canadian Short Rates##br## To Remain Well-Anchored Chart 15Go Long A Canadian 2/10 ##br## Barbell Vs. The 5yr Bullet Australia - Flattening Phase Ahead A small flattening of the Australian yield curve over the next 12 months is currently priced into the forwards. This expectation seems reasonable to us, but the bulk of the flattening should come from the short end where yields will drift higher over the course of the year. Australian inflation prospects are improving, with the Melbourne Institute Inflation Gauge having stabilized of late. As the negative impact of imported goods price deflation recedes going forward, domestic inflation should rise. In addition, our model is calling for core CPI inflation to grind higher in 2017 (Chart 16). Chart 16Australian Inflation Is Bottoming... Chart 17...Even As Australian Growth Is Starting To Cool Because of this, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) will progressively become less dovish and greater odds of a rate hike will be priced into the yield curve. This is already starting to happen, on the margin; since October, the probability of a rate cut by December 5th, 2017 has decreased substantially, from 65% to 5%. As we have been pointing out over the past several months, the Australian economy has been humming along. China's policy reflation seen earlier in 2016 had a direct positive impact on Australian export demand, while a rising terms of trade fueled by higher base metals prices has provided a boost to domestic income. However, the upward pressure on yields from accelerating domestic growth has become milder of late. Employment growth, motor vehicle sales and aggregate private sector credit growth are now all trending to the downside (Chart 17). This might be an indication that the boom from the first half of this year is starting to dissipate. This tames, to some extent, our optimism over the Australian economy. If economic activity continues to slow modestly, corporate bond supply, i.e. demand for credit and liquidity, should ease. In turn, this should also alleviate the recent upside pressure on the longer part of the Australian government bond yield curve. Chart 18The NZ Curve Will Follow##br## The Forwards In 2017 In sum, on a 3-6 month horizon, the short end of the Aussie curve could edge higher as the market prices in a less dovish RBA that will need to begin worrying about rising inflation once again. While at the same time, longer-term bond yields might have seen their highs given some cooling of economic growth. We already have a recommended position on the Australian curve to benefit from these trends, as we are short the 4-year government bond bullet versus a long position in the 2-year/6-year barbell. This trade was initiated earlier this year, has generated +13bps of profits so far, and remains valid.8 As an exit strategy, we will re-evaluate this trade if high-frequency cyclical Australian data disappoint further or the current expansion of Australia's terms of trade starts to reverse. New Zealand - Following The Forwards The New Zealand forward yield curve is currently pricing a 12bps flattening over the next 12 months, with the 2-year/10-year slope expected to move from 107bps to 95bps (Chart 18). This move seems reasonable to us. As we discussed in a recent report, inflation will re-surface in New Zealand in 2017.9 The upside surprise will be due to those factors: Narrowing global output gaps that will bring about a more inflationary global backdrop. A boost from China, most notably through higher producer prices. A weakening of the Kiwi dollar in response to a more hawkish Fed. A stronger dairy sector, which should help New Zealand's exports and reflate domestic wages. A potential reversal of migration inflows, which should shrink the supply of workers and tighten the labor market, boosting wage growth and pressuring price inflation higher. If this view materializes, the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) will become more hawkish. This should push short term yields higher and flatten the New Zealand government bond yield curve. Like everywhere else, the New Zealand yield curve has steepened over the last month as global bond markets have priced in faster growth and the potential impact of Trump-ian fiscal stimulus in the U.S. As this external impact dissipates in the next few months, the main factor driving the shape of the New Zealand curve will swing back to expectations of future RBNZ policy. Bottom Line: The recent consistent steepening of government bond yield curves across the developed markets should soon begin to fade, leading to a more diverse evolution of curves during the course of 2017: steeper in the U.S., core Europe and in the long end in Japan; flatter in the U.K., Canada, Australia and New Zealand. Robert Robis, Senior Vice President Global Fixed Income Strategy rrobis@bcaresearch.com Jean-Laurent Gagnon, Editor/Strategist jeang@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see BCA Global Fixed Income Strategy/U.S. Bond Strategy Weekly Report, "Six Reasons To Tactically Reduce Duration Exposure Now", dated July 19, 2016, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com & usbs.bcaresearch.com 2 Please see BCA Global Fixed Income Strategy/U.S. Bond Strategy Weekly Report, "The Fourth Tantrum", dated November 29, 2016, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com & usbs.bcaresearch.com 3 The current 1-year forward rate for the benchmark 10-year U.S. Treasury is 2.67% 4 Please see BCA Global Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "Better U.S. Economic Data Will Cause The Dollar To Strengthen", dated October 14, 2016, available at gis.bcaresearch.com 5 The Fed targets headline PCE inflation, while inflation compensation in U.S. TIPS is priced off headline CPI inflation. The historical gap between the two measures is about 40bps, thus a level of breakeven inflation in TIPS that is consistent with the Fed's 2% inflation target is 2.4% (2% PCE inflation + 0.4%). 6 Please see BCA Global Fixed Income Strategy Weekly Report, "The ECB's Next Move: Extend & Pretend", dated October 25, 2016, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com 7 Both the Bank of Canada and the median economist surveyed by Bloomberg forecast 2.0% real GDP growth in 2017. For further details, please http://www.bankofcanada.ca/2016/10/mpr-2016-10-19/ 8 Please see BCA Global Fixed Income Strategy Weekly Report, "Five Yield Curve Trades For The Rest Of The Year", dated May 24, 2016, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com 9 Please see BCA Global Fixed Income Strategy Weekly Report, "A Post-Trump Update Of Our Overlay Trades", dated November 22, 2017, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com The GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. The Custom Benchmark Index Recommendations Duration Regional Allocation Spread Product Tactical Trades Yields & Returns Global Bond Yields Historical Returns
GAA DM Equity Country Allocation Model Update The GAA DM Equity Country Allocation model is updated as of November 30, 2016. The model further augmented the overweight to the U.S. despite the fact that the U.S. had already been the largest overweight, at the expenses of the Euro Area. Japan's underweight is reduced again, albeit slightly. The model continues to dislike Canada and Australia even though the two countries have outperformed year to date. U.K. remains the largest underweight (Table 1). Table 1Model Allocation Vs. Benchmark Weights As shown in Table 2 and Chart 1, Chart 2 and Chart 3, the large overweight of the U.S. versus the non-U.S. (Level 1 model) worked well in November with 49 bps of outperformance versus the MSCI World benchmark, the level 2 (allocation within the 11 non-U.S. countries), however, underperformed significantly, resulting the overall model to underperform by 16 bps. Please see also on the website http://gaa.bcaresearch.com/trades/allocation_performance. Table 2Performance (Total Returns In USD) Chart 1GAA DM Model Vs. MSCI World Chart 2GAA U.S. Vs. Non U.S. Model (Level1) Chart 3GAA Non U.S. Model (Level 2) For more details on the models, please see the January 29th, 2016 Special Report "Global Equity Allocation: Introducing the Developed Markets Country Allocation Model." http://gaa.bcaresearch.com/articles/view_report/18850. GAA Equity Sector Selection Model The GAA Equity Sector Selection Model (Chart 4) is updated as of November 30, 2016. Table 3AllocationsTable 4Performance Since Going Live Chart 4Overall Model Performance The momentum component has shifted Consumer Discretionary from underweight to overweight. For mode details on the model, please see the Special Report "Introducing The GAA Equity Sector Selection Model," July 27, 2016 available at https://gaa.bcaresearch.com. Xiaoli Tang, Associate Vice President xiaoli@bcaresearch.com Patrick Trinh, Senior Analyst patrick@bcaresearch.com Aditya Kurian, Research Analyst adityak@bcaresearch.com
Highlights Commodity prices and the dollar can occasionally rise together. The 1999-2001 and the 2005 experiences suggest a supply shock is required. If commodities were to rally alongside a strengthening dollar in 2017, this would be an oil-led move. Metals have very little potential upside as improving DM growth drains liquidity from EM economies. Favor petro currencies (CAD and NOK) relative to the antipodeans (AUD and NZD). Stay short AUD/CAD. USD/JPY is in a major bull market. However, near-term risks are to the downside. Feature It has become axiomatic among investors to assume that a dollar bull market is synonymous with a commodity bear market. While the relationships usually holds, there have been episodes where the narrow trade-weighted dollar and natural resource prices moved in tandem, not in opposite directions: 1982 to 1984, 1999 to 2001, and in 2005. The recent surge in base metals raises that possibility, but as DM economies suck in global liquidity away from EM ones, the prospect for a positive correlation between most commodities and the dollar is still remote. When Do Commodities And The Dollar Walk Together? Commodities and the dollar usually move in opposite direction. Since 1980, there has only been three episodes of consistent commodity strength despite dollar appreciation: 1982 to 1984, 1999 to 2001, and in 2005 (Chart I-1). What defines each of these episodes? In the early 1980s, the rally in commodities was concentrated outside of the energy complex. The U.S. economy was rebounding from the 1980s double-dip recession, and Japan was in the middle of its economic miracle. Their vigorous growth resulted in a large positive demand shock, boosting Japan and the U.S.'s share of global copper consumption from 34% to 37%. This undermined any harmful effect on metal prices from a rising dollar (Chart I-2). Chart I-1Commodities Can Rise ##br##Alongside The Dollar Chart I-2Early 1980s: U.S. Growth Was ##br##Able To Boost Metal Prices From 1999 to 2000, the rally in commodity was not broad based. In fact, it was concentrated in the energy sector (Chart I-3). It reflected three factors: After being decimated in 1997 and 1998, EM stock prices managed to stage a temporary rebound; one that mostly reflected bombed out equity and currency valuations. However, the muted response of non-oil commodities suggests that this rebound had little economic impact. Energy was buoyed by the vigorous growth in DM, with OECD oil consumption growing 1% annually between 1998 and 2001. Finally, as oil prices fell below US$10/bbl in late 1998 global oil production contracted sharply, plummeting by more than 4 million barrels, or 5% of total production. Not only could Saudi Arabia and Russia not withstand the pain of lower oil prices, but the latter was in the midst of a massive economic crisis that disrupted the local oil industry's ability to finance its operations. While most commodities in the 2005 episode experienced subtle upward drift, once again, energy was the true winner (Chart I-4). Supply disruptions in the Gulf of Mexico following the record-breaking 2004 and 2005 hurricane seasons contributed to removing slightly more than one million barrels from the market. Additionally, oil had captured investors' imagination, with the peak-oil theory being all the rage. This combination explains why oil was the primary beneficiary of Chinese and EM economic strength while base metals could not overcome the dollar's hurdle. Chart I-31999-2001: Commodity##br## Rally Was An Oil Rally Chart I-42005: Commodity##br## Rally Was An Oil Rally Bringing it all together, the dollar and commodities where able to rise as one in the 1980s because they responded to the same positive U.S. growth shock. However, during the 1999-2001 and 2005 commodity rallies in the face of strong dollar, the supply/demand imbalance in oil was paramount. Bottom Line: The dollar and commodity prices can occasionally move together. This happens when a supply shock affects a natural resource as important as oil, lifting its price despite the greenback hurdle. Outside of energy, in general prices still displayed little upside through these episodes. Giant Sucking Sound Our bullishness on the dollar is built on our positive outlook for U.S. growth and rates, a view only reinforced by Trump's electoral victory.1 This does not mean we expect the same boost to metal consumption that we saw in the early 1980s. Today, combined Japanese and U.S. copper consumption only accounts for 11% of global consumption. For iron ore, the U.S. represents only 4% of global consumption. Even if the U.S. were to spend $1trillion over five years on infrastructure (an extremely optimistic assumption), it will not constitute the same relative boost to global demand as the U.S. expansion during the 1980s did (Chart I-5). Additionally, metals will remain slightly oversupplied. In fact, inventories have been rising and more supply of iron ore is coming upstream in 2017, as additional Pilbara iron ore deposits are being unleashed on the markets. In the case of copper, our commodity specialists expect supply to continue to grow in the years ahead. But still, could EM lift the demand for metals enough to play the same role as the U.S. did in the early 1980s? We doubt it. When it comes to China, the current growth improvement is likely as good as it gets. The Keqiang index - a measure of industrial activity in the Middle Kingdom - is approaching post-2011 highs, but the demand for loans remains very depressed (Chart I-6). Moreover, the Chinese fiscal impulse - which has buoyed the country's economy for much of 2016 - has rolled over and is now in negative territory, suggesting that the Keqiang index will weaken in 2017. This will weigh on Chinese imports of machinery and raw materials, representing a deflationary shock for other EM. Chart I-5Metals Are About China, Not The U.S. Chart I-6China: The Best Is Behind Us At the current juncture, additional deflationary forces on EM would be an unwelcomed development. The structural headwinds plaguing EM economies are still in place. EM remain burdened by too much capacity, too much debt, and too little productivity (Chart I-7). More worryingly, strong DM growth will do very little to lift EM economies and assets out of their structural funk. Instead, DM strength is likely to hurt EM. As Chart I-8 shows, since 2009 improvements in DM leading economic indicators (LEIs) have led to falling EM LEIs. Chart I-7EM Structural Headwinds Chart I-8DM Hurting EM EM nations are not very dependent on DM as a source of growth. Intra EM trade has been responsible for most of the growth in EM exports as shipments to the DM economies and the U.S. now account for only 28% and 15% of EM total exports, respectively. While this explains why DM growth cannot lift EM growth, it still does not explain why DM growth leads to deteriorating EM activity. The glue binding this paradox is global liquidity. In a nutshell, when DM growth improves, DM economies suck in global liquidity, which results in a tightening of EM monetary and financial conditions. This combined constriction acts as a large brake on EM growth. Underpinning the relationship between liquidity and growth are a few relationships: First, DM real rates are a relatively clean measure of growth expectations. As Chart I-9 shows, U.S. real yields and the growth expectations embedded in U.S. stocks prices correlate closely with each other. Second, when DM real yields rise, EM reserve accumulation - a measure of high-powered liquidity - moves into reverse (Chart I-10). This suggests that rising DM real yields prompt investors to abandon EM markets, attracted by improving risk-adjusted returns in DM. Chart I-9Real Interest Rates: ##br##A Read On Expected Growth Chart I-10The Liquidity ##br##Channel Third, rising DM rates puts downward pressure on EM FX (Chart 10, bottom panel). Being associated with a reversal of carry trades this is another indication that capital is leaving EM economies. Additionally, falling EM exchange rates tighten EM financial conditions by hampering the financial viability of EM borrowers with foreign currency debt. Fourth, given that the exogenously-driven fall in liquidity already hurts EM growth, rising EM borrowing costs in response to increasing DM real rates amplify the economic drag. By causing the return on EM bonds to fall (Chart I-11), this generates further outflows from EM, and also tightens EM financial conditions. Finally, rising DM yields have been associated with underperforming EM equities relative to DM equities (Chart I-12), giving investors another reason to pull money out of EM. These dynamics have implications for commodity currencies. BCA's view is that DM real yields have upside from here, and therefore EM liquidity and financial conditions are set to tighten. Not only will this hurt EM assets, but a flattening BRICs yield curve should also lead to falling commodity currencies (Chart I-13). Chart I-11The Financial ##br##Channel Chart I-12EM/DM Stocks: A Function ##br##Of DM Real Rates Chart I-13Tightening EM Liquidity Conditions##br## Hurt Commodity Currencies However, differentiation is needed. Tightening EM liquidity and financial conditions are likely to hurt the metal market where there is no broad-based supply deficit. However, like in the late 1990s, oil could actually do well under a strong dollar scenario. For one, the OECD and the U.S. represent much larger shares of oil demand than they do for industrial metals (Chart I-14). In the context of robust U.S. economic growth and consumer spending, we could see continued upward momentum in global oil demand. This is crucial as the oil market is already in a deficit following the collapse in oil capex in 2015 and 2016 (Chart I-15). Additionally, our Commodity and Energy Strategy team argues that OPEC and Russia are very likely to cut production next week. Economic strains and the desire for asset sales in Saudi Arabia and Russia are creating the needed incentives.2 In this environment, oil currencies (CAD and NOK) should outperform antipodeans (AUD and NZD). The outlook for the AUD is the poorest. It is the currency most exposed to metals, the segment of the commodity market most aligned with EM growth. NZD could be at risk too. While it is not exposed to metals like the AUD, the kiwi is very exposed to EM spreads, a variable that is likely to suffer if DM yields continue to rise.3 Buying a basket of CAD and NOK relative to AUD and NZD makes sense here. In terms of our trades, we shorted AUD/CAD too early. However, the economic backdrop described above suggests that the economic rationale for this trade is growing ever more potent. In fact, from late December 1998 to January 2000, CAD rallied against the USD, while the AUD was flat. Additionally, technicals and positioning point to a favorable entry point at the current juncture (Chart I-16). Chart I-14Oil Is Still About The U.S. Chart I-15Favorable Supply/Demand Backdrop For Oil Chart I-16A Good Entry Point For Shorting AUD/CAD Bottom Line: In 2017, the relationship between commodity prices and the dollar is likely to resemble the 1999-2001 outcome. While tightening EM liquidity conditions could weigh on metals, supply concerns and a strong U.S. economy could lift oil prices. This environment would favor the CAD and the NOK relative to the AUD and the NZD. A Countertrend Bounce In The Yen? As we discussed last week, the move in USD/JPY makes sense based on the BoJ policy dynamics we analyzed in our September 23 report titled "How Do You Say "Whatever It Takes" In Japanese?". However, despite our bearish disposition toward the yen, we worry that a countertrend correction in USD/JPY is in the offing. USD/JPY is approaching a formidable resistance. The tell-tale sign of a USD/JPY bull market has been when the pair moves above its 100-week moving average (Chart I-17). We do expect such a move to ultimately materialize. However, with the 100-week MA currently at 114.8, this key indicator is a stone throw away from the present exchange rate of 113.39 and might prove to be a temporary resistance. Additionally, a congestion zone exists between 113 and 114.5, reinforcing this risk. Increasing the danger at the 114 level is the recent high degree of groupthink behavior displayed by this pair. As was the case for the U.S. bonds, the fractal dimension measure for USD/JPY is now below 1.25, highlighting the risk of a countertrend move (Chart I-18). Chart I-17USD/JPY: Key Resistance In Sight Chart I-18A Countertrend Move In USD/JPY Moreover, we agree with our U.S. Bond Strategy service and expect a pause in the U.S. bond sell-off.4 With the tight relationship between USD/JPY and 10-year Treasury yields fully alive, any rebound in bond prices would imply a rebound in the yen. Finally, our intermediate-term timing indicator shows that USD/JPY is 5% overvalued on a tactical time frame, a level where the likelihood of a temporary reversal is heightened. Based on the above observations, today we are opening a tactical short USD/JPY position at 113.39, with a target of 107 and a stop at 115.2. We are also closing our long NOK/JPY trade at a profit of 5.3%. Bottom Line: While the cyclical outlook for USD/JPY continues to point upward, tactically, USD/JPY is facing some downside risk. We are implementing a tactical short USD/JPY trade with a target at 107 and closing our long NOK/JPY trade. Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, "Dollar: The Great Redistributor", dated October 7, 2016, and Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, "Reaganomics 2.0?", dated November 11, 2016, available at fes.bcaresearch.com 2 Please see Commodity & Energy Strategy Weekly Report, "The OPEC Debate", dated November 24, 2016, available atces.bcaresearch.com 3 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Special Report, "Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market", dated September 16, 2016, available at fes.bcaresearch.com 4 Please see U.S. Bond Strategy Weekly Report, "Toward A Cyclical Sweet Spot?", dated November 22, 2016, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 The dollar has crossed a crucial resistance level, and the DXY is now trading close to 102. Positive data this month have contributed to this rally. Durable goods orders came in at 4.8% for October, up from 0.4% in September. This has lifted manufacturing PMI for November to 53.9, showing strength in the supply side of the U.S. economy. Minutes from the November 1-2 FOMC meeting indicate a clear hawkish consensus for December's meeting. A probability of a hike is now fully priced in and is reflected in the almost 14-year high reached by the DXY following the release of the minutes. We should see some stability in the DXY coming up to the December meeting. Otherwise, the U.S. economy seems strong. Upcoming data should ultimately buoy the strength in the dollar, but short-term movements will be limited. Report Links: One Trade To Rule Them All - November 18, 2016 Reaganomics 2.0? - November 11, 2016 When You Come To A Fork In The Road, Take It - November 4, 2016 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Draghi remains resolute in his commitment to reach the inflation target. Easy monetary policy has helped support recent growth in the euro area. Low policy rates have increased credit supply, leading to higher lending volumes to households, NFCs and SMEs. Key indicators, such as this month's composite PMI which went up to 53.7, from 53.3, highlight continued decent growth in Europe. Nevertheless, core inflation remains weak at 0.75%, which entails a high likelihood for easy policy going forward. Persistently low rates and structural weaknesses will continue to weigh on bank profitability. Banks may eventually respond by limiting credit growth in the future and hampering overall activity. The short-run outlook for the Euro still remains solid against crosses. EUR/USD has hit a support level, but momentum indicates strong downward pressure against the dollar, so attention to this resistance level is warranted. Report Links: When You Come To A Fork In The Road, Take It - November 4, 2016 Relative Pressures And Monetary Divergences - October 21, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 USD/JPY has appreciated by more than 7% since the day Donald Trump was elected president. From 1990 up until the day Trump got elected, the yen depreciated at such a high rate in such a short time frame in only 4 occasions. We are taking a tactical short position in USD/JPY, because although we continue to be yen bears on a cyclical basis, the current sell-off seems overdone. USD/JPY has reached highly overbought technical levels and it is near its 100-week moving average of 114.8, which should act as a temporary resistance. More importantly, the sell-off in U.S. bond yields, a major driver of the recent plunge in the yen is likely to pause for the time being. USD/JPY will once again become an attractive buy at around 107. Report Links: One Trade To Rule Them All - November 18, 2016 When You Come To A Fork In The Road, Take It - November 4, 2016 USD, JPY, AUD: Where Do We Stand - October 28, 2016 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 On Wednesday the Treasury released its Autumn Statement, outlining fiscal policy for the coming year. Philip Hammond, Chancellor of the Exchequer, offered no surprises as he vouched to continue to rebalance the budget, albeit at a slower pace. The fiscal impulse looks to increase slightly, yet stay negative for the next 4 years. Such a hawkish fiscal stance should be a drag on growth in an economy that cannot afford any setbacks as it prepares to exit the European Union. However, despite this grim outlook we are still monitoring the pound as an attractive buy, given that it is very cheap. In fact GBP/USD had very little movement after the announcement, which suggests that much of the risks for the U.K's economic outlook are already priced into the cable. Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 The Australian economy continues to encounter structural weaknesses from a deteriorating mining sector, for which the outlook remains pessimistic. An interesting observation is that the mining investment-cut is considerably mature, as RBA Assistant Governor Christopher Kent states "about 80% of the adjustment" is done. However, weak Asian EM fundamentals and a questionable outlook for China imply impending demand-side problems, which will weigh, not only on Australian terms of trade, but also the Australian economy, as emerging Asia represents 66% of Australia's total exports. An additional hurdle for the terms of trade is a rising USD, which could drag down commodity prices and the AUD. In the short run, the MACD line for AUD/USD also points to downside in the near future, as the currency approaches a possible resistance level at 0.72. Report Links: One Trade To Rule Them All - November 18, 2016 When You Come To A Fork In The Road, Take It - November 4, 2016 USD, JPY, AUD: Where Do We Stand - October 28, 2016 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 We continue to hold a bearish stance towards NZD/USD, as the dollar bull market and weakness in Asian currencies will ultimately weigh on the kiwi. However, the outlook for the NZD against other commodity producers is not as clear. Prices for dairy products, which constitute over 30% of New Zealand exports, have skyrocketed and are now growing at 46% YoY. This trend is set to continue in the short term, as Chinese dairy imports continue to rebound, recording a 9.7% growth rate compared to last year. Furthermore, real GDP is growing at a 3.5% pace, the highest in the G10. That being said, we are reticent to be too bullish on this currency, as inflation remains very low and increasing migration is putting a lid on wages. However if inflation picks up, the NZD could become attractive relative to its commodity peers. Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 The Fed is Trapped Under Ice - September 9, 2016 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data has come out below expectations: Core CPI came in at 1.7%. Wholesale sales are contracting at -1.2%. Retail sales excluding autos are at 0%. These figures support the view that there is an underlying weakness in the Canadian economy which will keep the BoC from reaching its inflation target. However, as the U.S. continues to be the largest consumer of oil in the world, with around 20% of global consumption, stronger U.S. growth will support oil demand, which in conjunction with tighter supply, will support oil prices. This will support the CAD against other commodity producing currencies. Structural weaknesses and an upward trend in USD/CAD since May suggest that the CAD could experience more downside momentum against USD. Nevertheless, it is important to monitor next week's OPEC meeting, the outcome of which will dictate the CAD. Report Links: When You Come To A Fork In The Road, Take It - November 4, 2016 Relative Pressures And Monetary Divergences - October 21, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 The decline in EUR/CHF appears to have subsided for the time being. Last week we mentioned that the SNB would not tolerate much more downside on this cross, and would not be shy to intervene if necessary. This view has shown to be valid, as EUR/CHF has found support around 1.07. This floor imposed by the SNB means that the performance of the franc against the dollar should mirror EUR/USD for the time being. This implies that USD/CHF should have limited upside in the short term, as EUR/USD has hit a major support level around 1.05 that has been in place for the last 2 years. On a cyclical basis, monetary divergences should continue to weigh against the euro, which makes us bullish on USD/CHF on this time frame. Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 Clashing Forces - July 29, 2016 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 The U.S. continues to be world's largest consumer of crude oil, with 20% of total consumption, while China leads in both the copper and nickel markets, accounting for nearly half of global consumption and consuming over 5 times as much as the U.S. in both markets. This divergence implies that if U.S. outperforms the rest of the world, and if the rising dollar continues to weigh on EM economies, oil should outperform base metals in the commodity space and consequently petro currencies like the NOK should outperform other commodity currencies. Additionally the NOK is supported by a current account surplus of 6%, and high inflation is prompting Norges Bank to back off from its dovish stance. While we like the NOK on its crosses, we are more bearish on the NOK versus the USD, as USD/NOK remains very sensitive to the dollar. Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 The Swedish economy continues to show signs of strength. Recent data supports this view: Consumer confidence for November is at 105.8, compared to 104.8 for October. Producer Price Index came in at 2.2% annually for October. A strong consumer sector has lifted inflation expectations in Sweden. Strong PPI numbers validate this, as they foretell a potential rise in CPI as producers pass on their costs to consumers. Despite this strength, SEK may see limited upside. As mentioned last week, most of the movement in the SEK can be attributed to the USD. Rate hike expectations have now been fully priced in for the Fed, so it is likely that movements in the USD will be muted, and hence the SEK could find some support, at least for now. Report Links: One Trade To Rule Them All - November 18, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
The Tactical Asset Allocation model can provide investment recommendations which diverge from those outlined in our regular weekly publications. The model has a much shorter investment horizon - namely, one month - and thus attempts to capture very tactical opportunities. Meanwhile, our regular recommendations have a longer expected life, anywhere from 3-months to a year (or longer). This difference explains why the recommendations between the two publications can deviate from each other from time to time. Highlights In November, the model underperformed global equities and the S&P in USD and in local-currency terms. For December, the model reduced its allocation to cash and stocks and boosted its weighting in bonds (Chart 1). Within the equity portfolio, most of the decrease in allocation came at the expense of EM, Sweden, Netherlands, U.S., and New Zealand. The model increased its weighting in Swedish, French, U.K., and Canadian bonds. The risk index for stocks deteriorated in November, while the bond risk index improved significantly. Chart 1Model Weights Feature Performance In November, the recommended balanced portfolio lost 1.5% in local-currency terms and was down 3.4% in U.S. dollar terms (Chart 2). This compares with a gain of 1.3% for the global equity benchmark, and a 3.7% gain for the S&P 500 index. Given that the underlying model is structured in local-currency terms, we generally recommend that investors hedge their positions, though we do provide recommendations from time to time. The sharp bond selloff and weakness in EM equity markets both took a toll on the model's performance in November. Weights The model cut its allocation to stocks from 66% to 53%, and increased its bond weighting from 26% to 47%. The allocation to cash was brought down to zero from 8%, while commodities remain excluded from the portfolio (Table 1). The model trimmed its allocation to Latin American equities by 4 points, Sweden by 3 points, and the Netherlands by 3 points. Also, weightings were reduced in U.S., New Zealand, Spanish, and Emerging Asian stocks. In the fixed-income space, the allocation to Swedish paper was boosted by 12 points, France by 7 points, Canada by 5 points, the U.K. by 3 points, and Italy by 1 point. Allocation to New Zealand bonds was decreased by 6 points and U.S. Treasurys by 1 point. Chart 2Portfolio Total Returns Table 1Model Weights (As Of November 24, 2016) Currency Allocation Local currency-based indicators drive the construction of our model. As such, the performance of the model's portfolio should be compared with the local-currency global equity benchmark. The decision to hedge currency exposure should be made at the client's discretion, though from time to time, we do provide our recommendations. The dollar appreciated significantly in November following the U.S. presidential election. Our Dollar Capitulation Index spiked and is currently at levels that suggest the rally in the broad trade-weighted dollar could pause (Chart 3). Chart 3U.S. Trade-Weighted Dollar* And Capitulation Capital Market Indicators The momentum indicator for commodities has moved further into overbought territory, pushing up the overall risk index. This asset class remains excluded from the portfolio (Chart 4). The deterioration in the liquidity and momentum indicators has lifted the risk index for global equities to the highest level in over 2 years. Our model cut its weighting in equities for the fourth month in a row (Chart 5). Chart 4Commodity Index And Risk Chart 5Global Stock Market And Risk The risk index for U.S. stocks increased sharply in November. With stocks reaching new highs, the model trimmed its allocation to this bourse. The markets took note of the growth-positive aspects of Trump's policies, but seem complacent about the stronger dollar, higher interest rates, and the potential for trade protectionist policies (Chart 6). The risk index for euro area equities has ticked up slightly in November. However, unlike its U.S. peers, it remains in the low-risk zone. Above-trend growth could provide support for euro area equities. (Chart 7). Chart 6U.S. Stock Market And Risk Chart 7Euro Area Stock Market And Risk The risk index for Dutch equities ticked up slightly and the model has downgraded this asset. That said, the weighting in Dutch equities remains the highest among its euro area counterparts (Chart 8). Improvements in the value and momentum measures for Latin American stocks have been largely offset by a deteriorating liquidity reading. As a result, the risk index did not decline much after the selloff. The model decreased its allocation to this asset (Chart 9). Chart 8Dutch Stock Market And Risk Chart 9Latin American Stock Market And Risk Over the course of only a few months, the risk index for bonds has swung from an extremely high risk level to the low-risk zone. Momentum has been the primary driving force behind this move and currently suggests that yields could pull back in the near term (Chart 10). The risk index for U.S. Treasurys declined significantly in November. While the model used the latest selloff to boost its allocation to bonds, it preferred to add allocation to bond markets outside of Treasurys. (Chart 11). Chart 10Global Bond Yields And Risk Chart 11U.S. Bond Yields And Risk After the rise in yields, Canadian bonds are massively oversold based on our momentum measure. The extremely low-risk reading has prompted the model to allocate to this asset (Chart 12). German bonds are oversold, but the reading on the cyclical measure has become considerably more bund-unfriendly. The model opted not to include bunds in the overall boost to its bond allocation. (Chart 13). Chart 12Canadian Bond Yields And Risk Chart 13German Bond Yields And Risk The risk reading in French bonds is more favorable than for bunds. Apart from oversold momentum, the value reading has also improved. The model increased its allocation to French bonds (Chart 14). The cyclical component of the risk index for Swedish bonds keeps moving in a bond-bearish direction. But that is completely overshadowed by extremely oversold conditions. In fact, the overall risk index for Swedish bonds is the lowest within our bond universe. Much of the increase in overall bond allocation ended up in Swedish paper (Chart 15). Chart 14French Bond Yields And Risk Chart 15Swedish Bond Yields And Risk Following sharp gains, the 13-week momentum measure for the U.S. dollar has reached levels at which some consolidation may take place. But the recovery in the 40-week rate of change measure indicates that it would probably be a pause in the dollar bull market rather than a trend change. With the December rate hike baked in, the Fed's communication about the policy next year holds the key to the path of the dollar - in addition to the fiscal policy of the next administration (Chart 16). The Japanese yen has been a major victim of the dollar rally. The 13-week momentum measure is approaching levels that halted the yen weakening trend in 2013 and 2015. However, this time around, it is not coupled with the same signal from the 40-week rate of change measure. The BoJ is sticking to its easy monetary policy, and some additional support on the fiscal front could drag the yen lower, notwithstanding a possible hiatus in the short term. Short term the yen could benefit from an EM pullback (Chart 17). After the latest bout of depreciation, the euro seems poised for another attempt to break below 1.05. The 13-week and 40-week momentum measures do not preclude this from happening. However, it would probably take the ECB to reaffirm its dovish message to push EUR/USD technical indicators into more oversold territory (Chart 18). Chart 16U.S. Trade-Weighted Dollar* Chart 17Yen Chart 18Euro Miroslav Aradski, Senior Analyst miroslava@bcaresearch.com
BCA will be holding the Dubai session of the BCA Academy seminar on November 28 & 29. This two-day course teaches investment professionals how to examine the economy, policy, and markets; and also makes links between these important factors. Moreover, it represents a great networking opportunity for all attendees. I look forward to seeing you there. Best regards, Mathieu Savary Highlights Donald Trump's victory represents a sea-change for U.S. politics as well as the economy. His expansionary fiscal policy, to be implemented as the labor market's slack evaporates, will boost demand, wages, and will prove inflationary. The Fed will respond with higher rates, boosting the dollar. EM Asian currencies will bear the brunt of the pain. Commodity currencies, especially the AUD, will also be significant casualties. EUR/USD will weaken in the face of a strong greenback, but should outperform most currencies. Key risks involve gauging whether the Fed genuinely wants to create a "high-pressure", economy as well as the potential for Chinese fiscal stimulus. Feature Trump's electoral victory only re-enforces our bullish stance on the dollar. A Trump presidency implies much more fiscal stimulus than originally anticipated. Therefore, the Fed will not be the only game in town to support growth. This strengthens our view that, on a cyclical basis, the OIS curve still underprices the potential for higher U.S. interest rates. In a Mundell-Fleming world, this suggests a much higher exchange rate for the greenback. Additionally, Trump's protectionist views are likely to hit EM economies - China in particular - harder than DM economies. We continue to prefer expressing our bullish dollar view by shorting EM and commodity currencies. Is Trump Handcuffed? Trump's victory reflects a tidal wave of anger and dissatisfaction with the current state of the U.S. economy. Most profoundly, his candidacy was a rallying cry against an increasingly unequal distribution of economic opportunities and outcomes for the U.S. population. As we highlighted last week, since 1981, the top 1% of households have seen their share of income grow by 11%. In fact, while 90% of households have seen their real income contract by 1% since 1980, the top 0.01% of households have seen their real income increase more than five-fold (Chart I-1). Chart I-1The (Really) Rich Got Richer In this context, Trump's appeal, more than his often-distasteful racial or gender rhetoric, has been his talk of protecting the middle class. But, by losing the popular vote, are his hands tied? Marko Papic, BCA's Chief Geopolitical Strategist, surmises in a Special Report1 sent to all BCA's clients that it is not the case. First, Trump's victory speech emphasized infrastructure spending, indicating that this is likely to be his first priority. As Chart I-2 illustrates, there is a lot of room for the government to spend on this front. At 1.4% of GDP, government investment is at its lowest level since World War II. Furthermore, according to the Tax Policy Institute, Trump's current plan includes $6.2 trillion in tax cuts over the next 10 years. Second, the Republican Party now controls Congress as well as the White House. Not only has the GOP historically rallied around the president when all the levers of power are in the party's hands, but also, the Tea party has been one of Trump's most ardent supporters. Hence, Trump's program is unlikely to be completely squelched by Congress. Third, the GOP is most opposed to government spending when Democrats control the White House. When Republicans are in charge of the executive, the GOP is a much less ardent advocate of government stringency, having increased the deficit in the opening years of the Reagan, Bush I, and Bush II administrations (Chart I-3). Chart I-2Room To Increase##br## Infrastructure Spending Chart I-3Republicans Are Fiscally Responsible ##br##When It Suits them Finally, international relations are the president's prerogative. While there are legal hurdles to renegotiate treaties like NAFTA, Trump can slap tariffs easily, rendering previous arrangements quite impotent. Though protectionism has not been highlighted in Trump's victory speech, the topic's popularity with his core electorate highlights the risk that trade policies could be impacted. Bottom Line: Trump has a mandate to spend and got elected because of his policies that support the middle class. His surprise victory represents a sea-change, a move the rest of the Republican establishment will not ignore. Therefore, we expect Trump to be able to implement large-scale fiscal stimulus. Economic Implications To begin with, Trump is a populist politician. While populism ultimately ends badly, it can generate a growth dividend for many years. Nowhere was this clearer than in 1930s Germany, where Hitler's reign yielded a major economic outperformance of Germany relative to its regional competitors (Chart I-4).2 Government infrastructure spending played a large role in this phenomenon. Also, the Reagan era shows how fiscal stimulus can lead to a boost to growth. From the end of the 1981-82 recession to 1987, U.S. real GDP per capita outperformed that of Europe and Japan, despite the dollar's strength in the first half of the decade. Fascinatingly, the U.S. GDP per capita even outperformed that of the U.K., a country in the midst of the supply-side Thatcherite revolution (Chart I-5). This suggests that the U.S's economic outperformance was not just a reflection of Reagan's deregulatory instincts. Chart I-4Populism Can Boost Growth Chart I-5Reagan Deficits Boosted Growth Too Unemployment is close to its long-term equilibrium, and the hidden labor-market slack has greatly dissipated. Additionally, one of the biggest hurdles facing small businesses is finding qualified labor. In the context of a tight labor market, we anticipate that Trump's fiscal stimulus will not only boost aggregate demand directly, but will also exert significant pressures on already rising wages (Chart I-6). Compounding this effect, if Trump does indeed focus on infrastructure spending, work by BCA's U.S. Investment Strategy service shows that this type of stimulus offers the highest fiscal multiplier (Table I-1).3 Chart I-6Stimulating Now Will Feed Wage Growth Table I-1Ranges For U.S. Fiscal Multipliers Additionally, a retreat away from globalization, and a move toward slapping more tariffs and quotas on Asia and China would be inflationary. Historically, falling inflation has coincided with falling tariffs as competitive forces increase. This time, with the output gap closing, and the tightening labor market, decreasing the trade deficit could arithmetically push GDP above trend, accentuating wage and inflationary pressures. Finally, for households, a combination of rising wages, elevated consumer confidence, and low financial obligations relative to disposable income could prompt a period of re-leveraging (Chart I-7). Moreover, the median FICO score for new mortgages has fallen from more than 780 in 2013 to 756 today, an easing in lending standard for mortgages. All the factors above suggest that U.S. growth is likely to improve over the next two years, driven by the government and households. It also points towards rising inflationary pressures. As we have highlighted before, the more the economy can generate wage growth to support domestic consumption, the more it becomes resilient in the face of a stronger dollar. The tyranny of the feedback loop between the dollar and growth will loosen. This environment would be one propitious for the Fed to hike interest rates as the economy becomes less dependent on lower rates for support. In the long-run, the Trump growth dividend is likely to require a payback, but this discussion is for another day. Bottom Line: Trump is likely to boost U.S. economic activity through fiscal stimulus, especially infrastructure spending. Since the slack in the economy is now small, especially in the labor market, this increases the likelihood that the Fed will finally be able to durably push up interest rates (Chart I-8). Chart I-7Household Debt Load Can Grow Again Chart I-8Vanishing Slack = Higher Rates Currency Market Implications The one obvious effect from a Trump victory is that it re-enforces our core theme that the dollar will strengthen on a 12 to 18-months basis as the market reprices the Fed's path. However, we expect Asian currencies to be viciously hit by this new round of dollar strength. For one, compared to the drubbing LatAm currencies received, KRW, TWD, and SGD are only trading 13%, 9%, and 15% below their post 2010 highs. Most importantly though, EM Asia has been the main beneficiary of 35 years of expanding globalization. Countries like China or the Asian tigers have registered world-beating growth rates thanks to a growth strategy largely driven by exports (Chart I-9). Chart I-9Former Winners Become Losers Under Trump We expect these economies and currencies to suffer the most from Trump's retribution and from a continued structural underperformance of global trade. China, Korea, and co. are likely to be hit by tariffs under a Trump administration. Also, under a Trump administration, the likelihood of implementation of new international trade treaties is near zero. Therefore, the continuous expansion of globalization of the previous decades is over, and may even somewhat reverse. Furthermore, a move toward a more multipolar world, like the interwar period, tends to be associated with falling trade engagement. Trump's desire to diminish the global deployment of U.S. troops would only add to such worries. Regarding the RMB, the picture is murky. On the one hand, the RMB is trading 4% below fair value and does not need much devaluation from a competitiveness perspective. However, Chinese internal deflationary pressures, courtesy of much overcapacity, remain strong (Chart I-10). Easing these pressures requires a lower RMB. Moreover, the offshore yuan weakened substantially in the wake of Trump's victory, yet the onshore one did not, suggesting that the PBoC is depleting its reserves to support the currency. This tightens domestic liquidity conditions, exacerbating the deflationary forces in the country. Chart I-10Plenty Of Excess Capacity In China This means that China is in a bind as a depreciating currency will elicit the wrath of president Trump. The risk is currently growing that China will let the RMB fall substantially between now and January 20. Such a move would magnify any devaluating pressures on other Asian exchange rates. While it is difficult to be bullish MXN outright on a cyclical basis when expecting a broad dollar rally, the recent weakness in MXN is overdone. Mexico has not benefited nearly as much from globalization as Asian nations. Also, after a 60% appreciation in USD/MXN since June 2014, even after the imposition of tariffs, Mexico will still be competitive. Even then, the likelihood and severity of any tariffs enacted on Mexico might be exaggerated by markets. In fact, President Nieto's invitation to Trump last summer may prove to have been a particularly uncanny political move. Investors interested in buying the peso may want to consider doing it against the won, potentially one of the biggest losers from a Trump presidency. Outside of EM, the AUD is at risk. Australia sits in the middle of the pack in terms of economic and export growth during the globalization era, but it is very exposed to Asian economic activity. Historically, the AUD has been tightly correlated with Asian currencies (Chart I-11). Adding insult to injury, Australia is a large metals producer, which means that Australia's terms of trade are highly levered to the Chinese investment cycle, the main source of demand for iron ore, copper, etc. (Chart I-12). With China already swimming in over capacity, unless the government enacts a new infrastructure package, Chinese imports of raw materials will remain weak. Chart I-11AUD Will Suffer If Asian Currencies Fall Chart I-12China Is The Giant In The Room The NZD is also likely to suffer against the USD. The currency's sensitivity to the dollar strength and EM spreads is very high. However, we expect AUD/NZD to remain depressed. The outlook for relative terms of trades supports the kiwi as ag-prices will be less impacted by a slowdown in Chinese capex than metals. Additionally, on most metrics, the New Zealand economy is outperforming that of Australia (Chart I-13). The CAD should beat both antipodean currencies. First, it is less sensitive to the U.S. dollar or EM spreads than both the AUD and the NZD, reflecting its tighter economic link with the U.S. We also expect some softer rhetoric and actions from Trump when it comes to implementing trade restrictions with Canada than with Asia. Finally, while we are very concerned for the outlook for metals, the outlook for energy is superior. Yes, a strong greenback is a headwind for oil prices, but a Trump presidency is likely to result in strong household consumption. Vehicle-miles-driven growth would remain elevated, suggesting healthy oil demand from the U.S. Meanwhile, our Commodity & Energy Strategy service expects the drawdown in global oil inventories to accelerate, particularly if Saudi Arabia and Russia can agree on a 1mm b/d production cut at the upcoming OPEC meeting at the end of the month, which is bullish for oil (Chart I-14). Chart I-13Stronger Kiwi Domestic Fundamentals Chart I-14Better Supply/Demand Backdrop For Oil We also remain yen bears. The isolationist stance of Trump is likely to incentivize Abe to double down on fiscal stimulus, especially on the military. Japan is currently massively outspent on that front by China (Chart I-15). With the BoJ pegging policy rates at 0% for the foreseeable future, the yen will swoon on the back of falling real yields. Moreover, if our bearish stance on Asian currencies materializes itself, this will put competitive pressures on the yen, creating an additional negative. For the euro, the picture is less clear. The euro remains the mirror image of the dollar, so a strong greenback and a weak euro are synonymous. Additionally, Trump stimulus, if enacted, will ultimately result in higher nominal and real yields in the U.S. relative to Europe, especially as the euro area does not display any signs of being at full employment (Chart I-16). That being said, the euro is currently very cheap, supported by a current account surplus, and the ECB might begin tapering asset purchases in the second half of 2017. Combining these factors together, while we remain cyclically bearish on EUR/USD - a move below parity over the next 12-18 months is a growing possibility - the euro will outperform EM currencies, commodity currencies, and even the yen. We are looking to buy EUR/JPY, especially considering the skew in positioning (Chart I-17). Chart I-15Japan Will Spend More On Its ##br##Military With Or Without Trump Chart I-16European Labor Market##br## Slack Is Evident Chart I-17EUR/JPY Has##br## Room To Rally Finally, the outlook for the pound remains clouded until we get a better sense of the High Court's decision on the government's appeal regarding the need for a Parliamentary vote on Brexit. We expect the court's decision to re-inforce the previous ruling, which means that the pound could strengthen as the probability of a "soft Brexit" grows. The resilience of the pound in the face of the recent dollar's strength points to such an outcome. Risk To Our View And Short-Term Dynamics The biggest risk to our view is obviously that Trump's fiscal plans never pan out. However, since our bullish stance on the dollar predates Trump's electoral victory, we would therefore remain dollar bulls, albeit less so. Nonetheless, limited fiscal stimulus would likely cause a temporary pullback in the dollar. Chart I-18A Mispricing Or A Signal? Another short-term risk is the Fed. Currently, inflation expectations in the U.S. have shot up. If the Fed does not increase rates in December - this publication currently thinks the FOMC will increase rates then - the dollar will fall as this move will put downward pressures on U.S. real rates. This is especially relevant as the 5-year/5-year forward Treasury yield stands at 2.8%, in line with the Fed's estimate of the long-term equilibrium Fed funds rates as per the "dots". A big risk for our EM / commodity currency view is China. China may not respond to Trump by aggressively bidding down the CNY before January 20. Instead, to counteract the negative effect of Trump on Chinese export growth, China might instigate more fiscal stimulus, plans that always have a large infrastructure component. The recent parabolic move in copper needs monitoring (Chart I-18). Bottom Line: A Trump victory is a massive boon for the dollar. However, because Trump represents a move away from globalization, the main casualties of the Trump-dollar rally will be Asian currencies and the AUD. The CAD and the NZD will also undergo downward pressures, but less so. Finally, while EUR/USD is likely to fall, the euro will outperform EM currencies, commodity currencies, and the yen. As a risk, in the short-term, an absence of Fed hike in December would represent the biggest source of weakness for the dollar. Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Geopolitical Strategy Special Report, "U.S. Election: Outcomes And Investment Implications", dated November 9, available at gps.bcaresearch.com 2 To be clear, while we do find some of Trump comments over the past year highly distasteful, we are not suggesting that he is a re-incarnation of Hitler or that his presidency is doomed to end in a massive global conflict. It is only an economic parallel. 3 Please see U.S. Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "Policy, Polls, Probability", dated November 7, available at usis.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "We are going to fix our inner cities and rebuild our highways, bridges, tunnels, airports, schools, hospitals. We're going to rebuild our infrastructure, which will become, by the way, second to none. And we will put millions of our people to work as we rebuild it." - U.S. President Elect Donald Trump (November 9, 2016) Report Links: When You Come To A Fork In The Road, Take It - November 4, 2016 USD, JPY, AUD: Where Do We Stand - October 28, 2016 Relative Pressures And Monetary Divergences - October 21, 2016 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "I'm very skeptical as far as further interest rate cuts or additional expansionary monetary policy measures are concerned -- over time, the benefits of these measures decrease, while the risks increase" - ECB Executive Board Member Sabine Lautenschlaeger (November 7,2016) Report Links: When You Come To A Fork In The Road, Take It - November 4, 2016 Relative Pressures And Monetary Divergences - October 21, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "In order for long-term interest rate control to work effectively, it is important to maintain the credibility in the JGB market through the government's efforts toward establishing sustainable fiscal structures" - BoJ Minutes (November 10, 2016) Report Links: When You Come To A Fork In The Road, Take It - November 4, 2016 USD, JPY, AUD: Where Do We Stand - October 28, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "[The impact of a weak pound on inflation]... will ultimately prove temporary, and attempting to offset it fully with tighter monetary policy would be excessively costly in terms of foregone output and employment growth. However, there are limits to the extent to which above-target inflation can be tolerated" - BOE Monetary Policy Summary (November 3, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Inflation remains quite low...Subdued growth in labor costs and very low cost pressures elsewhere in the world mean that inflation is expected to remain low for some time" - RBA Monetary Policy Statement (October 31, 2016) Report Links: When You Come To A Fork In The Road, Take It - November 4, 2016 USD, JPY, AUD: Where Do We Stand - October 28, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Weak global conditions and low interest rates relative to New Zealand are keeping upward pressure on the New Zealand dollar exchange rate. The exchange rate remains higher than is sustainable for balanced economic growth and, together with low global inflation, continues to generate negative inflation in the tradables sector. A decline in the exchange rate is needed" - RBNZ Governor Graeme Wheeler (November 10, 2016) Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 The Fed is Trapped Under Ice - September 9, 2016 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "We have studied the research and the theory behind frameworks such as price-level targeting and targeting the growth of nominal gross domestic product. But, to date, we have not seen convincing evidence that there is an approach that is better than our inflation targets" - BoC Governor Stephen Poloz (November 1, 2016) Report Links: When You Come To A Fork In The Road, Take It - November 4, 2016 Relative Pressures And Monetary Divergences - October 21, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "We don't have a fixed limit for growing the balance sheet; it's a corollary of our foreign exchange market interventions - which we conduct to fulfill our price stability mandate" - SNB Vice-President Fritz Zurbruegg (October 25, 2016) Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 Clashing Forces - July 29, 2016 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Banks' capital ratios have doubled since the financial crisis and liquidity has improved. At the same time, some aspects of the Norwegian economy make the financial system vulnerable. This primarily relates to high property price inflation combined with high household indebtedness" - Norges Bank Deputy Governor Jon Nicolaisen (November 2, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "...the weak inflation outcomes in recent months illustrate the uncertainty over how quickly inflation will rise. The Riksbank now assesses that it will take longer for inflation to reach 2 per cent. The upturn in inflation therefore needs continued strong support" - Riksbank Minutes (November 9, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Dazed And Confused - July 1, 2016 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
Highlights Despite a tough week, the dollar bull market is intact. The U.S. economy's resilience to a strong dollar is growing. But, if Trump wins, the dollar could temporarily sell off against EUR, CHF, and JPY. Favor these currencies against EM and commodity currencies. Thanks to the High Court's Brexit ruling, the outlook for the pound is brightening. Wait for the appeal procedure to be over before implementing directional bets. Feature Despite this week's violent correction in the dollar, we remain dollar bulls. However, the recent reaction of the greenback to the rising probability of a Trump victory raises the need to hedge such an outcome. Still Bullish On The Dollar... The U.S. is unlikely to fall from its perch at the top of the distribution of G10 interest rates, a historically dollar-bullish environment (Chart I-1). Chart I-1Dollar Tailwinds The hidden slack in the U.S. labor market has dissipated. The amount of workers outside of the labor force who do want a job is at 6.2%, a level in line with the readings recorded between 2000 and 2007, when hidden slack was low (Chart I-2). Moreover, wages and salary continue to grow in the national income. Skewing the income distribution away from profits and rents is akin to a redistribution of income away from the top 1% of households, who derive nearly 50% of their income from profits. Importantly, middle-class households have a much higher marginal propensity to consume than rich ones. So great is the difference that since 1981, the 10% increase in the share of national income accruing to the top 1% of households has helped depress consumption by 3%. As a result, income redistribution will depress the U.S. savings rates going forward (Chart I-3). Since 70% of household consumption is geared toward the service sector, a component of the economy where productivity growth is hard to come by, increasing consumption is likely to directly result in job creation. Chart I-2U.S. Wages Can Rise Chart I-3The U.S. Savings Rate Has Downside With the unemployment gap being closed, consumption growth will cause wage growth to accelerate, further supporting consumption. Hence, the Fed can increase rates more aggressively than the 70 basis points priced into the OIS curve until the end of 2019. These kinds of dynamics have historically been very dollar bullish (Chart I-4). Moreover, the feedback loop linking the dollar and financial conditions to the economy is weakening. Not only is the economy increasingly driven by household expenditures, but the weight of commodity and manufacturing capex in the economy has collapsed in response to the dollar's strength (Chart I-5). Even if the sensitivity of these sectors to the dollar and financial conditions is unchanged, their impact on the broad economy has diminished. Chart I-4A Virtuous Circle##br## For The Dollar Chart I-5Lower Impact Of Manufacturing ##br##And Commodities Outside of the U.S. some key factors will prevent a normalization of policy rates in the major economies. Euro area rates will stay depressed for much longer. Conditions to generate inflation are absent. The output gap remains wide and negative, unemployment is significantly above NAIRU, and fiscal austerity, while diminished, is still de rigueur (Chart I-6). While the IMF pegs the output gap at 1.2% of GDP, the ECB estimates it to stand at 6% of GDP. Additionally, the European credit impulse is likely to roll-over. European bank stock prices have led European credit growth. They now point to slowing loan growth (Chart I-7). Even if loan growth were only to stabilize, this would imply a fall in the impulse. Chart I-6Inflationary Pressures##br## In Europe Chart I-7Downside Risk To The##br## Euro Area Credit Impulse These forces will weigh on the euro. The SNB floor under EUR/CHF remains credible and exercised. Therefore, USD/CHF will mostly stay a function of EUR/USD. For Japan, as we highlighted in the September 23 and October 28 reports, conditions are falling into place to see rising wages and inflation expectations. Rates being pegged at 0% until inflation greatly overshoots 2% will lower Japanese real rates along with the yen. Bottom Line: The 12-18 months outlook for the dollar remains bright. The resilience of U.S households will lead to stronger wage growth and an economy powered by consumption. The Fed will surprise markets with more rate hikes than anticipated. Meanwhile, European and Japanese real rates are unlikely to rise much if at all. ...But The Short-Term Outlook Is Bifurcated Yet, the short-term outlook is murky. BCA believes that a Trump presidency is likely to supercharge any dollar rally. Not only would his presidency imply huge infrastructure projects, his trade tactics should put upward pressure on wages and inflation, prompting an even more hawkish Fed than we anticipate. However, if recent dynamics are any clue, a Trump victory next week could also cause an immediate but temporary knee-jerk sell-off in the dollar. Since the FBI announced a re-examination of the Clinton emails affair, Trump's probability of winning has skyrocketed. While USD/MXN has rallied, so has EUR/USD, driven by a favorable move in interest rate differentials (Chart I-8). This raises the specter of a bifurcated move in the dollar over the next month or so. On the one hand, the dollar could rise against EM currencies and commodity producers, but suffer against EUR, CHF, and JPY. Why would the dollar rise against EM and commodity currencies? Cyclically and tactically, the stars are lining up against this set of currencies. The economic situation in EM and China is as good as it gets right now. The Keqiang index is near cyclical highs, suggesting that the upswing in Chinese industrial activity is unlikely to strengthen further, especially as loan demand remains tepid (Chart I-9). Chart I-8A Trump Indigestion Chart I-9China: As Good As It Gets Worryingly, Chinese fiscal stimulus is dissipating, which will act as a drag on the nation's investment and industrial activity. Chinese authorities panicked in 2015 as the Chinese economy was moving toward a hard landing. The government direct fiscal spending impulse surged (Chart I-10). Also, private-public partnerships originally expected to invest $1.2 trillion in infrastructure over three years were deployed in six months. As these tactics caused the economy to deviate from Beijing's stated goal to rebalance China away from investment, they are now being rolled back. Additionally, Chinese deflationary pressures are likely to resurface. Our bullish stance on the dollar implies a negative view on commodity prices. PPI will suffer if the dollar rallies given that Chinese producer prices are highly correlated with commodity prices (Chart I-11). This increases the likelihood that industrial activity in China will slow again. Chart I-10Vanishing Fiscal##br## Support Chart I-11Chinese PPI And Commodity Prices:##br## Brothers In Arms These risks are not priced in by EM assets and related plays. Risk reversals on EM currencies are priced in for perfection. Slowing Chinese growth would represent a negative surprise for EM debt, EM currencies, and commodity currencies (Chart I-12). An additional worry for EM currencies is momentum. A paper by the BIS shows that momentum continuation strategies are very profitable in EM FX.1 Hence, if EM currencies begin to fall, this fall will prompt further weaknesses. Finally, a Trump presidency is another headwind for EM and commodity currencies. In an earlier Special Report, we argued that a key factor that boosted the profitability of FX carry strategies was the rise of globalization (Chart I-13).2 This growing global trade mostly benefited small open economies, EM economies, and commodity producers, the so-called "carry-currencies". Trump's rhetoric promises a roll-back of this trend, a move that will disproportionally hurt such currencies. Compounding this risk, this cycle, the performance of FX carry trades has been inversely correlated to global bond yields (Chart I-14). BCA's underweight duration represents another problem for EM and commodity currencies. Chart I-12EM Plays Are Priced For Perfection Chart I-13Carry Trades Love Globalization Chart I-14Rising Yields Hurt Carry Currencies However, what could temporarily lift the euro, the Swiss franc, and the yen despite a negative cyclical outlook? Risk aversion and a global equity market correction prompted by a Trump victory. In short, a flight to safety amid uncertain times. These currencies are underpinned by current account surpluses ranging from 3% of GDP for the euro area to 10% for Switzerland. They therefore export investments abroad. This capital usually displays a strong home bias when global risks spike, and EUR, CHF, and JPY strengthen when global equities weaken. Finally, our current negative predisposition toward carry trades would also support funding currencies, currencies with deeply negative rates like EUR, CHF, or JPY. Bottom Line: In the direct aftermath of a Trump victory, the dollar could suffer from some temporary downward pressure against the EUR, CHF, and JPY. However, it will strengthen against EM and commodity currencies. On a cyclical basis, the USD will be stronger against these latter currencies than against European currencies. Key Investment Recommendations We are opening long EUR/AUD and short CAD/JPY positions. The EUR is less sensitive to EM downside than the AUD. Deteriorating EM currencies' risk reversals often coincide with a stronger EUR/AUD (Chart I-15). Also, the euro is cheaper than the Aussie, trading at a 5% discount to PPP. Additionally, EUR/USD could appreciate in the event of a Trump presidency, but its negative impact on EM economies and global trade will drag down AUD. The CAD/JPY position is primarily a Trump hedge. CAD will sell off if Trump wins as investors ponder the future of NAFTA. Meanwhile, the yen will benefit from safe-haven flows and from the eradication of any probability of MoF interventions (Chart I-16). Japan already meets two of the three criteria to be labeled a currency manipulator by the U.S. Treasury. Under a Trump presidency, such a label will have very real consequences. Chart I-15A Fall In EM Assets Would##br## Support EUR/AUD Chart I-16If Trump Wins, The MoF ##br##Will Not Intervene Moreover, CAD/JPY is also negatively affected by a deterioration of EM risk reversals. However, we are more worried for the JPY's long-term outlook than the EUR's. This is because of the more aggressive policy stance taken by the BoJ. Thus, this trade is more tactical than the EUR/AUD bet. Finally, investors wanting to play a Trump victory using European currencies should consider going long CHF/SEK. Sweden, a small open economy with deep trade links with EM, has been a key beneficiary of globalization. It will be a big loser if global trade shrinks. Meanwhile, CHF is likely to rally. Critically, this trade is for very nimble traders. At EUR/CHF 1.06, the SNB will intervene with all its might. The U.K.'s Über Thursday Yesterday, not only did the Bank of England announce its monetary policy decision and economic forecasts, but also, the High Court ruled that the Article 50 process preceding Brexit requires a vote from Parliament. While we expect Parliament to follow the popular vote and engage in Brexit, a parliamentary vote is much more likely to result in negotiating a "soft Brexit" rather than a "hard Brexit". In a "soft Brexit", the U.K. would retain access to the common market, and passporting of financial services would be allowed. However, freedom of movement would have to be maintained and the U.K. would have to contribute to the EU's purse. Unsurprisingly, the government is appealing the decision. Practically, this means it is still too early to aggressively bid up the pound. If the government wins its appeal, GBP/USD will move toward 1.10. If the government loses its appeal, FDI flows in the U.K. could regain some composure and help finance the large British current account deficit. This would lift GBP/USD toward 1.30 - 1.40. Probabilities are skewed toward the government losing its appeal. Economics, too, warrants caution. While the household sector's resilience has been a surprise to the Bank of England, it is unlikely to continue for long. First, the U.K. household credit impulse has rolled over and is now contracting at a GBP 1 billion pace, pointing to slowing growth. Second, in line with falling capex intentions, employers are paring their hiring intentions (Chart I-17). A slowdown in household nominal income growth should ensue. British households' real income will soon be squeezed, especially as the BoE increased it inflation forecast to 2.7% for 2018 due to the pass-through from the 15% fall in the trade-weighted GBP (Chart I-18). Additionally, the RICS survey points to further weakness in house prices. Chart I-17Deteriorating U.K. Labor Market Outlook Chart I-18Mechanics Of A Real Income Squeeze Hence, the BoE is on hold for a longer time than was anticipated in August. Moreover, Chancellor Hammond has made it clear that while the fall budget will loosen the fiscal austerity penciled in under the Osborne budgets, it is too early for investors to expect a large fiscal easing from the government. This suggests that risks remain tilted toward further easing by the "Old Lady." Bottom Line: Until we get clarity on the results of the government's appeal of yesterday's High Court Brexit ruling, we are inclined to fade strength in the pound. Any move above GBP/USD 1.25 would create a tactical shorting opportunity. A strangle with strikes at 1.27 and 1.15 and a January maturity makes sense for investors wanting to play the volatility around the ultimate ruling on the government's appeal. Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 Lukas Menkhoff, Lucio Sarno, Maik Schmeling and Andreas Schrimpf, "Currency Momentum Strategies", BIS Working Papers (2011). 2 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Special Report, "Carry Trades: More than Pennies And Steamrollers", dated May 6, 2016, available at fes.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "The Committee judges that the case for an increase in the federal funds rate has continued to strengthen but decided, for the time being, to wait for some further evidence of continued progress toward its objectives" - FOMC Statement (November 2, 2016) Report Links: USD, JPY, AUD: Where Do We Stand - October 28, 2016 Relative Pressures And Monetary Divergences - October 21, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "[On ECB Stimulus]...the initial date set to end the buying program is March, but the most advisable action is that it be a process that's as slow as possible" - ECB Governing Council Member Luis Maria Linde (October 28, 2016) Report Links: Relative Pressures And Monetary Divergences - October 21, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "[On wether the BOJ would buy regional domestic bonds]..Regional domestic bonds are issued by the various local governments, and are traded separately. There are various factors that would make it difficult to consider them for monetary policy, but we will give the suggestion due consideration" - BoJ Governor Haruhiko Kuroda (November 2, 2016) Report Links: USD, JPY, AUD: Where Do We Stand - October 28, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "...indicators of activity and business sentiment have recovered from their lows immediately following the referendum and the preliminary estimate of GDP growth in Q3 was above expectations. These data suggest that the near-term outlook for activity is stronger than expected three months ago" - BOE Monetary Policy Report (November 3, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "In Australia, the economy is growing at a moderate rate. The large decline in mining investment is being offset by growth in other areas, including residential construction, public demand and exports. Household consumption has been growing at a reasonable pace, but appears to have slowed a little recently" - RBA Statement (November 1, 2016) Report Links: USD, JPY, AUD: Where Do We Stand - October 28, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "There are several reasons for low inflation - both here and abroad. In New Zealand, tradable inflation, which accounts for almost half of the CPI regimen, has been negative for the past four years. Much of the weakness in inflation can be attributed to global developments that have been reflected in the high New Zealand dollar and low inflation in our import prices" - RBNZ Assistant Governor John McDermott (October 11, 2016) Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 The Fed is Trapped Under Ice - September 9, 2016 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "There are unconventional monetary policies that give us more room to maneuver than previously believed...These include pushing interest rates below zero or buying longer-term bonds to compress long-term yields" - BoC Governor Stephen Poloz (November 1, 2016) Report Links: Relative Pressures And Monetary Divergences - October 21, 2016 The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "In Switzerland the negative interest rate is currently indispensable, owing to the overvaluation of the Swiss franc and the globally low level of interest rates" - SNB President Thomas Jordan (October 24, 2016) Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 Clashing Forces - July 29, 2016 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "A period of low interest rates can engender financial imbalances. The risk that growth in property prices and debt will become unsustainably high over time is increasing. With high debt ratios, households are more vulnerable to cyclical downturns" - Norges Bank Governor Oystein Olsen (October 11, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "[On Sweden's financial stability]...it remains an issue because we are mismanaging out housing market. Our housing market isn't under control in my view" - Riksbank Governor Stefan Ingves (October 17, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Dazed And Confused - July 1, 2016 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
Highlights The U.S. is not yet a "high-pressure" economy, but slack is dissipating. U.S. growth, while not torrid, will remain high enough to push interest rates higher. The euro area continues to exhibit tepid domestic demand growth, and slack there remains higher than in the U.S. Monetary divergences will grow, weighing on EUR/USD. The Canadian economy displays underlying weaknesses which will prevent the BoC from hiking for an extended period of time. Stay long USD/CAD, but favor the CAD to the AUD and the NZD on a USD rally. Feature Following Janet Yellen's Boston speech last week, a new phrase has entered the lexicon of investors: "high-pressure economy". The speech was originally interpreted as a clarion call to let the economy overheat in order to absorb the slack created by the shock of 2008. However, Yellen still sees some slack in the economy. In her eyes, an easy monetary stance, at this point, will not cause an overheating, it will only bring back to the marketplace workers that had left the labor force. Chart I-1Drying Global Liquidity We have sympathy toward this view, especially when put in an international context where global capacity utilization remains depressed. Also, countries like China, Saudi Arabia, and Mexico have been intervening in the FX markets to preempt or limit downside to their currencies, tightening global liquidity conditions (Chart I-1). Nonetheless, the Fed Chair also highlighted that the FOMC did not want the U.S. economy to overheat as the domestic slack gets absorbed. Doing so would raise the risk that the Fed will have to then overcompensate by tightening rates very aggressively. This would prompt another recession. U.S.: Not High Pressure Yet, But... No indicator suggests that there is a burning need to quickly ratchet U.S. rates higher. However, domestic economic conditions are falling into place to justify a slow move toward higher rates. Our aggregate U.S. capacity utilization gauge is showing a dissipation of U.S. economic slack (Chart I-2, top panel). This is a side-effect of the tepid growth in the capital stock of U.S. businesses this cycle, which limits the expansion of the supply-side of the economy (Chart I-2, bottom panel). Meanwhile, household consumption should remain robust. Not only did 2015 register the strongest growth in the median household's real income since 1967, consumption is unlikely to slow much. In fact, vehicle-miles traveled and the Federal income tax receipts are both pointing toward healthy consumption (Chart I-3). Despite punky construction starts, housing activity shows signs of improvement. Housing inventories are near record lows and construction has underperformed household formation. Moreover, building permits are hooking upward, while housing affordability remains generous (Chart I-4). Additionally, the NAHB survey also points toward a rising share of residential activity in the economy (Chart I-4, bottom panel). Finally, capex intentions are slowly recovering. Moreover, the BCA House view is that the U.S. profit contraction is past its nadir. Going forward, capex and inventories are unlikely to subtract as much from growth as they did in 2015 and 2016. They may even become accretive to GDP growth. Chart I-2Vanishing U.S. Slack Chart I-3Positive Signs For The U.S. Consumer Chart I-4Residential Investment Will Improve Limited slack and a continued economic expansion imply a high likelihood of a Fed hike this year, and maybe two more next year if no shocks to financial conditions emerge. With markets currently pricing in 65 basis points of rate hikes by the end of 2019, this should lift rates across the curve. Higher interest rates on U.S. assets should drive private inflows into the country, pushing the U.S. dollar higher (Chart I-5). From a technical perspective, the U.S. capitulation index is breaking out to the upside following a pattern of lower highs. Since 2008, such breakouts have been followed by a significant rally in the broad trade-weighted dollar (Chart I-6). Thus, we continue to position ourselves for additional dollar strength this cycle. Chart I-5Flows Into The U.S. ##br##Are Set To Grow Chart I-6Favorable Technical ##br##Backdrop For The Greenback Bottom Line: The household sector remains healthy, and U.S. economic slack is dissipating. Hence, the Fed will try, rightfully or wrongly, to push rates higher this year and next, lifting the dollar in the process. Euro Area: Less Pressure A dollar rally could be painful for the euro. Yet, the euro is cheap and supported by a current account surplus of 3.3% of GDP (Chart I-7). What to do with this conflicting picture? For a currency to embark on a durable bull market, productivity growth needs to be stronger than that of its trading partners. A strong currency makes the tradeable-goods sector less competitive, hampering growth. A positive terms-of-trade shock, like that undergone by commodity producers during the previous decade can also do the trick. Neither of these statements currently describe the euro area. Another avenue for a country to withstand a strong currency is for growth to be domestically driven. If household consumption is the main locomotive, exporters' loss of market share do not hurt activity as much. This is true until the domestic economy enters a recession, an event usually driven by higher policy rates. This is why when the share of salaries in the U.S. economy expands, the dollar undergoes cyclical bull markets (Chart I-8). More salaries in the national income means more consumption. Chart I-7Euro ##br##Supports Chart I-8Domestically-Driven Growth##br## Is Good For A Currency In the euro area, GDP growth is above trend, but, in recent quarters, final private domestic demand has been weak (Chart I-9). In fact, last quarter, net exports were the main contributor to growth. This could explain why, since 2015, stronger European business surveys vis-à-vis the U.S. were unable to boost EUR/USD (Chart I-10). Chart I-9European Consumption##br## Isn't Strong Chart I-10If EUR/USD Could Not ##br##Rally Then, When Will It? We do expect eurozone final domestic demand to remain tepid. Yes, the credit impulse has improved, but this amelioration will prove temporary. The previous rebound in credit flows reflected the movement from a large contraction to a small expansion. Today, the dismal performance of euro area bank stocks - which have been a good leading indicator of European loan growth - points to slowing credit growth (Chart I-11). Fiscal policy is also moving from a small positive to a small negative. Work by the ECB staff shows that the cyclically adjusted budget balance in Europe fell by 0.3%, from -1.7% to -2.0% of GDP in 2016. Aggregate cyclically-adjusted budget balances are forecasted to improve to -1.8% and -1.6% of GDP in 2017 and 2018, respectively, representing a 0.2% fiscal drag each year. While a small number, we have to keep in mind that euro area trend growth is between 0.5% and 1%. This suggests that the European economy remains ill-equipped to handle a stronger euro. Moreover, the European economy exhibits much more slack than the U.S. economy. While total hours worked in the U.S. are 14% above Q1 2010 levels, in Europe, they are only 1.5% above such levels (Chart I-12), a gap much greater than demographics alone would have suggested. This means that monetary divergence will continue between Europe and the U.S. Chart I-11Euro Area Credit Impulse Will Weaken Chart I-12Less Capacity Pressures In Europe In fact, this week, the ECB did little to dispel this notion. Beyond trying to squash ideas of a sudden end to the QE program or any imminent tapering, president Draghi communicated that December will be the month when the real action occurs. Based on current trends, we expect the ECB to extend its QE program beyond March, but to hint at a tapering of purchases later in 2017. The ECB will also make it very clear that rates will remain as low as they currently are for an extremely long time. Thus, while the ECB might be slowly moving away from its hyper-stimulative stance, it will not do so as fast as the Fed. Therefore, policy divergences should continue to weigh on EUR/USD. Technicals are also pointing toward a lower euro. Not only has EUR/USD broken down its 1-year old series of higher lows, the euro's capitulation index, the intermediate-term momentum indicator, and the euro's A/D line are forming negative divergences with EUR/USD (Chart I-13). An interesting way to play the euro's weakness is to go short EUR/CZK, a position championed by our Emerging Market Strategy service.1 A floor at 27 has been set under EUR/CZK since November 2013. Yet, this floor looks increasingly untenable. Speculators are beginning to pile in. This week, 2-year Czech yields temporarily dipped below those of Swiss 2-year bonds, the current holder of the world's lowest yield. To fight appreciation pressures, the Czech National Bank (CNB) is accumulating a lot of reserves by buying euros, which is fueling a surge in the money supply (Chart I-14, top panel). Chart I-13Worrying Euro ##br##Technicals Chart I-14CZK: Reserves Expansion##br## Leading To Inflation This accumulation of reserves, in turn, is fanning inflationary forces in the Czech economy. The output gap is closing and core inflation already is increasing at a rate of 1.8% p.a. Easy financial conditions and expanding credit growth are likely to boost already-accelerating unit labor costs and wages (Chart I-14, bottom panel). This means that the 2% inflation target is likely to be hit as early as Q2 2017 according to the CNB. We expect this goal to be handily surpassed if the floor stays in place. Thus, we expect the CNB to abandon the floor within the next twelve months and we are shorting EUR/CZK. Finally, while we are bearish EUR/USD, we do believe that the euro will outperform the pound and commodity currencies. Moreover, despite poorer fundamentals, the euro could also temporarily outperform the SEK and the NOK if the dollar strengthens. The latter two are more sensitive to the USD than the euro is. Bottom Line: EUR/USD is at risk from the broad dollar rally. It is also likely to suffer from the tepid state of the euro area's final domestic demand, fueling monetary-policy divergences with the U.S. A speculative opportunity to short EUR/CZK is emerging, as the CNB's peg is outliving its usefulness. Canada: Falling Pressure USD/CAD has become more correlated with movements in rate differentials than with the vagaries of oil prices (Chart I-15). This puts the actions of the Bank of Canada in sharper focus. As expected, this week, the BoC left policy rates unchanged at 0.5%. More interesting was the quarterly monetary report. The economy has rebounded from the slump induced by the Q2 Alberta wildfires, and many key gauges of the Canadian economy have improved (Chart I-16). Yet, the BoC is looking the other way. Chart I-15CAD: Now More Rates Than Oil Chart I-16The BoC Is Looking The Other Way... The BoC is now forecasting the Canadian output gap to close in mid-2018; in July, this was expected to happen in the second half of 2017. This is because the BoC cut the expected Canadian growth rate by a cumulative 0.5% over the next two years. There have been some worrying developments warranting a more cautious forecast. While the Trudeau government's new childcare benefits are currently being rolled out and new infrastructure spending is to be implemented in 2017, the Canadian private sector's finances are increasingly shaky. The aggregate debt-servicing costs of the non-financial private sector is at record highs, with generous contributions from both households and the corporate sector (Chart I-17). The aggregate credit impulse has responded to this handicap, contracting by 7% of potential GDP, a move driven by the corporate sector (Chart I-18). While not as dramatic, the pace of debt accumulation by the household sector has also weakened. Recent administrative measures to cool the housing market - put in place by various provincial entities as well as the federal government - could accentuate this trend. Chart I-17...Rightfully So Chart I-18Collapsing Canadian Credit Impulse Another problem for Canada has been its loss of competitiveness. Non-oil Canadian exports have not responded as expected to the fall in the CAD. This is because many Canadian manufacturers have set up factories in Mexico and other EMs, or are competing with firms operating out of these nations. With these countries' currencies witnessing devaluations as deep as, or deeper than the loonie's, it is no wonder that Canada has lost market shares in the U.S. (Chart I-19). This means that Canadian rates will remain low for longer, making Canada another contributor to global monetary divergences vis-a-vis the U.S. The BoC is right to be worried that the Canadian economy will take longer than anticipated to close its output gap. With the pass-through to inflation of a lower CAD dissipating, the BoC expects Canadian core inflation to remain well contained for the next two years. We see little cause to disagree. This means that despite trading at a premium to PPP, USD/CAD has upside. Moreover, the Canadian dollar's A/D line is rolling over, another factor pointing to upside for USD/CAD (Chart I-20). At this point, the biggest risk to our view is oil. If WTI can breakout above $52 - perhaps in response to an as-yet negotiated OPEC/Russia oil-production cut or freeze - this could mitigate the downside for the CAD. Thus, while we like USD/CAD, we think the CAD has upside against the AUD and the NZD, especially as the loonie is less sensitive to the USD and EM spreads than the two antipodean currencies. Chart I-19Canada Is Losing Competitiveness Chart I-20Falling CAD A/D Line Bottom Line: The Canadian economy is showing surprising signs of underlying weakness. With the CAD having recently been more correlated to rate differentials than to oil, USD/CAD could rally on monetary divergences. That being said, on the back of a strong USD, CAD is likely to outperform the AUD and NZD. Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Emerging Markets Strategy Weekly Report, "Central European Strategy: Two Currency Trades", dated September 28, 2016, available at ems.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "The risks have changed in terms of overshooting what I think is full employment with implications for potential imbalances...Those imbalances might result in a reaction by the Fed that we end up having to tighten more quickly than I would like" - FOMC Voting Member Eric Rosengren (October 17, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "An abrupt ending to bond purchases, I think, is unlikely...We remain committed to preserving a very substantial degree of monetary accommodation" - ECB President Mario Draghi (October 20, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Since the employment situation has continued to improve, no further easing of monetary policy may be necessary... at any rate, I would like to discuss this thoroughly with other board members at our monetary policy meeting" - BoJ Board Member Yutaka Harada (October 12, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Our judgment in the summer was that we could have seen another 400,000-500,000 people unemployed over the course of the next few years...So we're willing to tolerate a bit of overshoot in inflation over the course of the next few years in order to avoid that situation, to cushion the blow" - BOE Governor Mark Carney (October 14, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "We have never thought of our job as keeping the year-ended rate of inflation between 2 and 3 percent at all times...Given the uncertainties in the world, something more prescriptive and mechanical is neither possible nor desirable" - RBA Governor Philip Lowe (October 17, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "There are several reasons for low inflation - both here and abroad. In New Zealand, tradable inflation, which accounts for almost half of the CPI regimen, has been negative for the past four years. Much of the weakness in inflation can be attributed to global developments that have been reflected in the high New Zealand dollar and low inflation in our import prices" - RBNZ Assistant Governor John McDermott (October 11, 2016) Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 The Fed is Trapped Under Ice - September 9, 2016 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "Given the downgrade to our outlook, Governing Council actively discussed the possibility of adding more monetary stimulus at this time, in order to speed up the return of the economy to full capacity" - BoC Governor Stephen Poloz (October 19, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "[On the effects of low interest rates on the housing market]...If you look at the recent past, the dynamics have been a bit more reassuring...[still]let's not forget, this disequilibrium that we have achieved remains very high" - SNB Vice-President Fritz Zurbruegg (October 12, 2016) Report Links: Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Global Perspective On Currencies: A PCA Approach For The FX Market - September 16, 2016 Clashing Forces - July 29, 2016 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "A period of low interest rates can engender financial imbalances. The risk that growth in property prices and debt will become unsustainably high over time is increasing. With high debt ratios, households are more vulnerable to cyclical downturns" - Norges Bank Governor Oystein Olsen (October 11, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 The Dollar: The Great Redistributor - October 7, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Policy Commentary: "[On Sweden's financial stability]...it remains an issue because we are mismanaging out housing market. Our housing market isn't under control in my view" - Riksbank Governor Stefan Ingves (October 27, 2016) Report Links: The Pound Falls To The Conquering Dollar - October 14, 2016 Long-Term FX Valuation Models: Updates And New Coverages - September 30, 2016 Dazed And Confused - July 1, 2016 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades

Global bond yields continue to grind higher, led by signs of improving growth, moderately higher inflation and central banks having difficulty staying credibly dovish. Maintain a below-benchmark duration stance.

As the U.S. median voter is shifting to the left, redistributive policy could come into play. A strong dollar helps to achieve this goal as it results in a bigger share of labor income in the economy. EM and commodity currencies could bear the brunt of the pain. Favor the euro on its crosses. Stay short CAD/NOK, but tighten stops.